Search Ocorian

Vincent Calcagno

Viewpoint: The valuation gap between public and private equities

19 October, 2026

Vincent Calcagno, Head of Growth, U.S.

Public markets defy higher rates

There is an uncomfortable tension in today’s asset prices. Government bond yields have risen sharply, increasing the return available without taking equity risk, while higher discount rates make future company profits less valuable in today’s money.

In theory that should push down share prices, yet listed equities are seen by some as eye-wateringly expensive. In the U.S., the Shiller CAPE ratio was 41.8 at the end of August 2026, above the 32.6 reached before the 1929 crash and only just below the dot-com-era record of 44.2. With valuations this high, the IPO market is on a tear, with proceeds surging, helped by the SpaceX mega deal. Sellers are cashing in.

But CAPE just tells us the market is historically vulnerable, not that a fall is imminent. 

FactSet expects S&P 500 earnings to rise 30% this year. That growth is dazzling investors while at the same time compressing valuation multiples and arguably blinding them to surging bond yields. But Effectively, today’s valuations assume companies can sustain exceptional profit growth and margin expansion. 

That is seductive ‘new paradigm’ talk. If the earnings surge proves cyclical, current public prices become much harder to justify even at more favorable multiples than investors have had for some time.

 

Private markets in the slow lane

Private equity has not experienced the same uplift in market value and still operates without the cheap leverage and easy multiple expansion that amplified returns in the last cycle.

Private-market investors may share the euphoria about future growth, but PE is constrained by financing as well. Debt represented 37% of entry multiples in 2025, against a 44% average between 2010 and 2022, according to McKinsey [7]. More expensive debt, and less of it in the capital mix, changes deal economics materially.

 

When buyers and sellers cannot agree

This can leave buyers and sellers looking at the same company very differently. Sellers may see strong listed markets, high recent transaction multiples and the valuation at which an asset has previously been carried, and resist a price cut. Buyers who are contributing more equity, paying more for debt, applying today’s higher discount rates, and seeing public market multiples move downward, find it harder to achieve the same target return at a given purchase price. Neither side has to go ahead, so the deal simply does not happen. KPMG [8] says H1 saw the slowest pace of exits in a decade.

That helps explain weak distributions. Bain puts buyout distributions as a share of NAV around 10 percentage points below the 2010–2020 average. The result is a huge inventory of ageing assets with the above McKinsey report saying 52% of global buyout firms have been held for more than four years, the highest proportion on record. 

The IMF [9] has warned that price discovery in private markets can take longer because transactions and participants are limited and valuations rely more heavily on irregular appraisals. Our survey captures the same tension: managers overwhelmingly expect exits to recover, yet 44% still cite valuation gaps between buyers and sellers as a factor influencing timing.

 

What could change the market weather?

In public markets higher growth rates and earnings are winning the conflict with higher discount rates leading to prices moving up. Conversely, private markets are simply doing fewer deals as holders refuse to mark or trade an asset down, are desperately trying to grow into sky-high private multiples.

So what’s next? The U.S. Treasury is intervening in the bond markets to relieve pressure on yields but fiscal consolidation is the only way to achieve that sustainably.  Bond investors should rightly be sceptical, and price accordingly.

High bond yields need not cause equity markets to correct if they are associated with rapid earnings growth. The more dangerous move is a rise in long-term yields driven by inflation, fiscal concerns or a higher term premium (the extra yield for holding long-dated debt). 

All of those forces are certainly present today. If continued profit growth can keep offsetting them – and respectable voices in the market are confident it will - elevated stock market valuations may persist and ultimately pull private market transaction pricing up. If it cannot – a position taken by equally respectable voices - the gap between public and private markets could close from the other direction.

Next section

Global Asset Monitor, October 2026 - Home page

Contact us

[7] McKinsey & Company, Global Private Markets Report 2026, “Private equity: Clearer view, tougher terrain”, February 2026
[8] KPMG, Q2’26 Pulse of Private Equity KPMG, 27 July 2026
[9] Global Financial Stability Report, October 2023; Chapter 1, “Soft Landing or Abrupt Awakening?”